The shirt shop
A customer walks into a shop and asks for a shirt. The assistant puts all 500 shirts on the counter at once. The customer panics and leaves.
A better assistant asks which style, then which colour, and then shows three shirts. The stock is the same. The order changed.
The lesson is to organise the choice. Clear headings and layout can do that without motion. Animation helps only when it makes a change or sequence easier to follow.
Four words, used precisely
| Word | What it means | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Animation | Anything that seems to move | A headline that rises into place |
| Transition | A change from one state to another | A menu that opens |
| Effect | The visible result of an action | A button that changes when you point at it |
| Interaction | An action that sets off a second action | A form label that moves when you start typing |
Teams that use one word for all four argue about the wrong thing. Ask which of the four a design calls for, and what it tells the reader.
Decide the order first
Motion starts with an order, not with an effect. The guide gives three ways to choose it:
- Top to bottom, the order a reader scans.
- By importance, the headline before the details.
- By structure: a section first, then its parts, then the items inside them.
The guide proposed the background first, then the logo, then the navigation. That was a direction for those designs, not a reason to delay navigation on every page.
Use only the movement the explanation needs. Large sweeps and staggered entrances can delay reading, even when their timing is consistent.
Speed belongs to the brand
A yoga studio's site can move slowly and softly. A gym's can move fast. One transition speed copied across every element and every project is a missing decision.
The guide was honest about our own site at the time. Our navigation took 3 seconds to finish loading, against about 1 second on a large technology brand's site.
What the 2019 guide left out: reduced motion
Some people get dizzy or sick from motion on a screen. Phones and computers have a setting for this, called reduced motion, and a site can read it.
Our current home page keeps its main text still. The capability panels use a short transition, and the phone header hides and returns as you scroll. The Reduce animation control switches those movements off; the panels and header also respect the device's reduced-motion preference.
The Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) set two limits worth knowing. Automatically moving content beside other content needs a pause, stop or hide control when it lasts more than five seconds, unless essential (level A). Non-essential motion triggered by interaction must be disableable at level AAA.
Five things to check in any design with motion
- What does each movement tell the reader? If nobody can answer, remove it.
- In what order does the page enter, and does that order match what matters most?
- Does the speed fit the brand, or is it one default copied everywhere?
- What happens with reduced motion switched on? Try it on your own phone.
- Can a person still use the page before the motion finishes? A button that cannot be clicked until it lands has made the reader wait for decoration.
Turn on reduced motion for a day. The movements you miss are the ones that were doing a job.